or


[10/01/09 - 12:37 AM]
The 10 Things You Need to Know About the New Season: #4 - Genre Doesn't Matter Either
By Brian Ford Sullivan (TFC)

Please note: As a courtesy, please do not reproduce these comments to newsgroups, forums or other online places. Links only please.

Welcome once again to "The 10 Things You Need to Know About the New Season," our annual feature about, well... the 10 things you need to know about the new season. The goal of this venture is to address not only common questions people have about television but to also demystify (or potentially reaffirm) stigmas out there about certain networks, time periods, genres and so forth. So with that in mind let us put on our journalistic caps and give you the cold hard truth about what's potentially ahead for some of your favorite new and returning shows...

4. No major genre fares better than another.

Are audiences giving up on traditional multi-camera sitcoms in favor of single-camera ones? Do dramas fare better than their comedic brethren? Or do reality shows perform the best? The answer to all the above: no. The truth is scripted and unscripted shows more or less succeed and fail at the same rate. Sure there are some problematic genres (animation, improv and newsmagazine) but the most prolific categories (multi-camera comedies, single-camera comedies, dramas, reality competition shows and docusoaps) all stay fairly close to the average 31% survival rate of new shows. Take a look at each genre's success rate in the past 10 years:


genreabccbsfoxnbcupnwbcwtotal
comedy
(animated)
0/1 (0%)0/1 (0%)1/2 (50%)0/3 (0%)0/2 (0%)1/3 (33%)2/12 (17%)
comedy
(improv/sketch)
2/4 (50%)0/6 (0%)1/6 (17%)2/5 (40%)5/21 (24%)
comedy
(multi-camera)
9/29 (31%)10/25 (40%)6/18 (33%)4/26 (15%)7/15 (47%)5/14 (36%)1/1 (100%)42/128 (33%)
comedy
(single-camera)
5/15 (33%)0/4 (0%)6/16 (38%)6/13 (46%)1/3 (33%)0/7 (0%)0/1 (0%)18/59 (31%)
drama17/58 (29%)24/52 (46%)12/46 (26%)16/52 (31%)3/16 (19%)10/24 (42%)3/9 (33%)85/257 (33%)
game show2/11 (18%)2/5 (40%)3/8 (38%)4/9 (44%)11/33 (33%)
newsmagazine2/14 (14%)1/2 (50%)0/1 (0%)3/17 (18%)
reality
(competition)
8/22 (36%)5/13 (38%)6/27 (22%)11/37 (30%)1/7 (14%)3/10 (30%)1/5 (20%)35/121 (29%)
reality
(documentary)
4/18 (22%)0/4 (0%)5/16 (31%)3/6 (50%)0/5 (0%)3/4 (75%)0/3 (0%)15/56 (27%)
sports1/1 (100%)1/2 (50%)2/3 (67%)
total50/173 (29%)41/104 (39%)40/141 (28%)46/154 (30%)12/48 (25%)24/67 (36%)5/20 (25%)218/707 (31%)


Among the more interesting trends: CBS has kept 40% of its new multi-camera shows around for a second season but none of its single-camera shows; NBC conversely is batting 46% for its single-camera comedies while just 15% for multi-camera ones. By the same token CBS has had success with 38% of its reality competition shows but none at all with its docusoaps whereas FOX and NBC have seen more failures in the former genre. All in all, you definitely can get the sense of each network's brand from the above data.

TOMORROW: Are cable channels really more patient than the broadcast networks?





  [october 2009]  
S
M
T
W
T
F
S
    


· SHOWATCH
(series past and present)
· DEVWATCH
(series in development)
· MOVIEWATCH
(tv movies and mini-series)





[09/24/26 - 07:01 AM]
Video: "Nobody Wants This" - Season 3 Official Trailer - Netflix
Joanne and Noah take their relationship to the next level amid sibling drama, maternal meddling and one giant leap of faith.

[09/24/26 - 06:11 AM]
Video: "Madden" - Official Trailer - Prime Video
Football wouldn't be football, without Madden.

[09/24/26 - 06:03 AM]
Video: "Treasure Island" (MGM+ 2026 Series) Official Trailer
A high-stakes reinvention of the classic, "Treasure Island" follows teenager Jim Hawkins and his formidable mother Bess as they're pulled into a deadly race for the treasure of the infamous Captain Flint.

[09/24/26 - 06:01 AM]
Apple TV Unveils First Look at "The Wanted Man"
The riveting eight-episode series will premiere globally on Wednesday, January 6, 2027, with the first two episodes, followed by one episode every Wednesday through February 17, 2027.

[09/24/26 - 05:18 AM]
Taylor Swift's New Single "Patient Zero" Music Video to World Premiere During the "2026 MTV Video Music Awards (VMAs)" Sunday, Sept. 27 on CBS
"Patient Zero" is Taylor Swift's new song from The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore, which is available to stream everywhere tomorrow, Friday, September 25.

[09/24/26 - 05:01 AM]
Tyson Fury vs. Anthony Joshua to Collide in Generation-Defining Heavyweight Showdown at Principality Stadium in Cardiff, Wales, Streaming Live on Netflix Friday, December 11
Widely regarded as two of the defining heavyweights of their era, Fury and Joshua have spent years atop the sport, collecting world championships and fueling one of boxing's most anticipated rivalries.

[09/23/26 - 04:00 PM]
Peacock Greenlights Gripping New Documentary "OJ's Accomplice"
The two-part documentary is set to premiere in December 2026.

[09/23/26 - 02:46 PM]
Paula Patton and Derek Luke Reunite Onscreen for New Lifetime Romance "Love on the Vineyard" as Part of the Love of a Lifetime Fall Slate
Patton stars as Jordan Wilson, a successful Washington, D.C., commercial real estate executive who returns to Martha's Vineyard with her teenage daughter after years away.

[09/23/26 - 01:25 PM]
David Mitchell Is Back on the Case, Breakout Mystery "Ludwig" Returns for Season Two on BritBox
Other October highlights include new seasons of "Celebrity Escape to the Country," "Time," and "Would I Lie to You?"

[09/23/26 - 11:01 AM]
Top 10 Most-Watched Prime Original Films & Series for the Week of September 14
"Reacher," "Neagley," "Sterling Point," "El Juicio," and "The Grand Tour" led all original series worldwide.

[09/23/26 - 11:00 AM]
Dolly Parton Tribute with Performance by Kacey Musgraves Set for the "2026 MTV Video Music Awards (VMAs)" Sunday, Sept. 27 on CBS
With three career nods, Musgraves is nominated this year in Best Country for "Dry Spell."

[09/23/26 - 10:31 AM]
"A Man on the Inside" Season 3 Adds New Guest Stars
The series will come to a conclusion when it returns for its third and final season, which begins production in San Francisco, California.

[09/23/26 - 10:23 AM]
NBC Debuts "St. Denis Medical" Season Three First Look
The series returns Monday, November 2 on the network.

[09/23/26 - 10:07 AM]
Blood, Benders and the Bridge: Paramount+ Is Headed to New York Comic Con with "Dexter: Resurrection," "Avatar: Seven Havens" and "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy"
From October 8-10, con-goers can catch first-looks, cast conversations and exclusive reveals from the three series.

[09/23/26 - 10:03 AM]
FOX Sports Feasts on Multi-Platform Presentation of 2026 NFL Thanksgiving Day Game Across FOX, FOX One, Tubi and FOX Deportes
This year's massive Thanksgiving Day game features the Dallas Cowboys and Philadelphia Eagles live in 4K.